Skip to main content

MHS: Revisiting Ethical Implications for Human Subject Research

A patient consents to HIV genotyping because their physician needs the information to select treatment. The patient is never meaningfully informed that the viral sequence will also enter a government surveillance system. Their sequence is subsequently identified as part of a rapidly growing molecular cluster. Public-health officials then use that classification to decide where and how to intervene. The individual never consented to having their clinical specimen repurposed to map their relationship to a population-level transmission network.

This creates a provocative comparison with conventional research ethics.

If I recruited 5,000 people living with HIV into a university study, collected their viral sequences, linked those sequences to demographic and epidemiological information, constructed molecular clusters, and evaluated interventions based on those clusters, an IRB would scrutinize questions of consent, risk, privacy, data governance, and protection of participants.

Yet when some similar analytical activities occur under the legal category of public-health surveillance, individual informed consent may not be required.

That gives you a powerful question for a research-ethics discussion:

At what point does surveillance become research on human populations?

From a Marxist/Foucauldian perspective, the critique could go further: the state has transformed biological material collected for an individual's medical care into population-level knowledge that permits institutions to classify, map, and intervene upon marginalized populations—without giving those populations equivalent control over the production or use of that knowledge. The ethical issue therefore isn't simply confidentiality; it is also who possesses the power to convert a person's biology into data, define the purposes for which those data may be used, and decide what constitutes an acceptable risk.

That argument is stronger than simply saying “MHS is experimentation without consent,” because the latter is legally debatable. The sharper critique is: classifying MHS as surveillance can permit practices involving systematic secondary analysis and intervention that would face substantially different consent requirements if institutionally classified as human-subjects research.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Surveillance V: Assembling the Eyes

  The Surveillance System  I'm listing the basic data collection tools used by local and state health departments- which report to CDC- first. Then I'll discuss how the epistemophilia of  this assembling inquisition machine is used. Here are the primary sources of information on PLHIV in the US that are collected and reported to CDC; and reused in other areas, the extend of which is unknown .  The Medical Monitoring Project  collects data on, and provides information about the behaviors, clinical outcomes, quality of care, and barriers to care and viral suppression among people with diagnosed HIV in the United States. Currently, 23 project areas (16 state health departments, 6 local health departments, and the Puerto Rico Department of Health) conduct MMP. eHARS  stands for Enhanced HIV/AIDS reporting system. It is the system used for HIV surveillance. eHARS collects data on all people living with HIV (PLWH) at the local and state level; and shares it ...

Navigating Sexuality while in Recovery

Essay outlining my thoughts and work on drug prevention programs used for scholarship application. Prompt. Rehab programs traditionally use individual and group counseling to help clients overcome addiction. In recent years, treatment protocols have evolved to include more holistic therapy options to support the recovery process. What is one alternative treatment approach that you think more rehab facilities should include in their programs? Why do you think alternative treatment methods need to be included with traditional methods as a part of the recovery process? Essay As a scholar with specific subject matter expertise in harm reduction epidemiology and recovery program development, and as an individual living with HIV and queer man with history of substance abuse whose work and life are deeply intertwined, I have experienced- and benefited from- the values of traditional treatment models as much as I have yearned for more integrative, holistic methods that address the interconnect...

Community Practicum Project

As a scholar with specific subject matter expertise in anthropology and public health, and as an individual living with HIV, a first generation college student, and queer man with history of substance abuse whose work and life are deeply intertwined, I have derived a lot of comfort and hope in bearing witness to the power of community coalitions while accompanying community leaders and advocates in mobilizing to take care of one another, to act, and to engage in necessary fights around issues that have long been in existence: universal and meaningful healthcare, abolition, housing rights, equal employment, gender equality, environmental justice, and rights of marginalized communities, displaced populations, migrants and immigrants. I have worked alongside community leaders, activists, and health and social providers in the field of HIV and disease prevention who have long refused to accept the status quo, and have instead, created their own forms of care or reimagined the existing sy...